Parenting 101: Sighs and Punishment
I suspect that civilization, as a whole, took a nosedive the very moment people started trying to reason with children. Children are, by nature, unreasonable. Children are basically egos with lungs and legs. Nonetheless, modern parents seem to spend an inordinate amount of time trying to coax, cajole and downright BEG their progeny to “please, for the love of all that is good and sane, BEHAVE!” Sometimes they even go so far as to promise treats and toys.
I try to imagine my mother allowing herself to stoop to this level – to no avail. The only “treat” I every enjoyed post-tantrum was being allowed to live.
Hiss. Do mothers not hiss anymore? In my day having your mother hiss at you was a tried and true way of life. A good hiss imparted ample wisdom in a quick exhale between clenched teeth. A hiss might say “you better behave yourself OR ELSE,” or “if you embarrass me, so help me GOD you will be sorry.” A covert hiss under a sunny parental smile was more than an exhale. It was a private expression of expectation between parent and child. Everyone knew the rules.
Another great tool in the arsenal of nearly every parent used to be the glare. It might be the narrowed eyes of a father saying, wordlessly, “watch it boy.” It might be the keen eye of a mother assessing the length of a skirt and finding it – and her daughter’s belief that she’d leave the house wearing it over her mother’s dead body – lacking.
For those parents more in line with a physical way of parenting, there was the grip. A firm grip on the shoulder or back of the neck let you know that your parent had both you and your behavior firmly in hand. Many a mother would smile brightly at her sassy child, leading anyone in the vicinity to believe she found his or her antics to be just as cute as Christmas. Meanwhile, a death grip on the child’s shoulder let them know that her smile was not only disingenuous, but concealed a dagger-like intent to address this transgression the very moment she had that child alone.
Pleading. Nowadays, all the good sleight of hand parenting seems to have fallen by the wayside, replaced with pleading and public placation. Nothing makes me sadder than to be out in public and witness to some poor, unfortunate soul laid bare by her inability to outwit a child.
“No, no honey, please don’t cry.” Mommy will say. The child continues wailing. “Mommy really doesn’t WANT you to have candy right now. We need to go home and eat yummy vegetables. Don’t you WANT to eat yummy vegetables and grow up big and strong like Superman (or Batman, or one of the cast members of “Lost,” or whoever the hero of the moment might be).” The child continues to flail around and make an absolute spectacle out of them both. All too often the parent in this scenario, sensing they are making a scene, will quickly capitulate to their captor’s demands in order to quiet the child.
Confident. I’m always loath to make lofty parenting assessments because my children are still young. I don’t think you can really break an arm patting yourself on the back until your children are well into middle age – if then. I’m sure Bernie Madoff’s mom would have been quite proud of how her boy turned out up until recently too. I’m a realist and know that plenty of perfectly nice families have gone on to see their offspring featured prominently on “America’s Most Wanted” so I try not to get overly confident. That said, I do feel qualified to state that when any child of mine ever acted that way in public (and they did) you never – ever – heard me pleading. Punishing? Probably. Pleading? Perish the thought.
My son was once removed from a “Friendly’s” restaurant because his behavior was anything but friendly. He was given fair warning that screeching loudly would lead to no good end. Nonetheless, despite my hiss AND a glare, he smiled broadly – boldly – and did it again. Bystanders thus witnessed the flashing blur of one small boy being removed from the restaurant by his overall straps. We caused a scene, indeed, but it was a USEFUL scene. I think a few people in the back might have applauded.
Although we are still very much a work-in-progress, I am happy to say that this incident happened over a decade ago and his table manners have been nearly impeccable both at home and away since.
When it comes to parenting, I’m all for fun, understanding and reason. Sometimes, however, you just need to get a really good GRIP on a situation.
Tags: grip, Parenting, punishment, threats |
7 Responses to “Parenting 101: Sighs and Punishment”
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Leave a comment
Comments are moderated and may not appear immediately in an effort to remove commercial messages, irrelevancies, excessive foul language, racist/sexist/hateful comments, spoofed/cloaked IPs and/or personal attacks and will be edited/deleted at our discretion. Thank you for your patience.




Posted
September 2, 2009 at
9:39 am by





1. bear
September 2, 2009 @ 8:03 pm
I completely agree! My SIL took the ‘reasoning’ approach with her children. The result is a three year old who runs the house instead of the parent. Parents need to grow a pair and set rules and guidelines and more importantly be consistant with them. If the child isn’t cooperating, punish them, take them out of the situation, and explain it to them later. You never take yourself down to a toddler’s level.
2. Lisa
September 7, 2009 @ 10:47 am
Love it! I totally agree. When I was growing up my mom never had to plead with me to be good and offer candy. She just gave me the death look and I knew what that meant. I don’t want to offer my child candy either. Kids need to learn that going to the store is a part of being in the family. We all do things we don’t like or don’t want to do but we do it because we are a part of a family. You don’t get “treats” for doing the normal tasks of life. I think all it takes is one firm follow through and your child won’t try it again because they know you mean business. Thanks for this article. It made me feel like their are still some well rounded parents out there.
3. Nanny Placement Agency
September 8, 2009 @ 9:58 am
Trying to a reason with a child almost always ends up in pleading, which is an undesirable state of affairs. All this mentioning of looks, hisses, and grips is enough to make many people think about, and clearly remember, their parents ways of handling them with they were young.
As the cliche goes, never surrender.
4. Cary Chugh
September 27, 2009 @ 8:52 am
Hi,
I was reading your website and I thought you might be interested in some new ideas on working with challenging kids. I am a clinical child psychologist and I just released my first (and hopefully only) book that re-interprets basic behavioral research in such a way as to enhance the types of rewards and punishments most parents, teachers, and professionals use. It’s called Don’t Swear with Your Mouth Full! When conventional discipline fails unconventional children and it explains why the typical strategies used in most settings are technically flawed. I then spell out an easier method of discipline called “behavior-limited discipline” that has not been written about before and has been receiving great reviews so far.
I am starting research on this new approach this fall and we are using this book as the treatment manual. Let me know if you you’re interested and I’ll send out a review copy tomorrow.
Thanks,
Cary
5. Stephani
October 21, 2009 @ 5:27 am
Well said. I hear too many tantrums in public these days. Your right there is no reasoning with children. Any attempt at it is insane. At least the kid who got the grip on his shoulder, isn’t going to be the reason people say ‘oh christ, here comes Kimberly and those brats’ when you are approaching the (chose one) school, playground, grandma’s house, the family reunion, church……. I rest easy knowing your kids will not be ruining any ones day because of their tantrums in a public place. I think we used to get a little of the hiss, a lot of the look, an occasional grip and also the flick of the finger on our shoulder or head in church if we were clowning around. But it must have worked because one time someone asked her if we ever pulled that kind of crap, as we were witnessing a tantrum in progress and she said (as she gave us that side ways glare) “you wouldn’t have dared”.
6. Kristen {The Freestyle Mom}
November 3, 2009 @ 2:47 am
I don’t get the reasoning concept all the time. My daughter is not yet 3, and people are constantly expecting me to reason with her. Sure, I can explain until I’m blue in the face that if she doesn’t let me brush her hair and put on her socks that she’s not going to the aquarium.
But until I’m dropping her off at Grandma’s and hauling the baby back to the car to go to the aquarium will she realize what just happened. And odds are she’s not going to realize it all started with the hair brush this morning. Her mind just doesn’t work that way. Hopefully by seventeen it will, but if not . . .
I will say, that I am still perfecting the evil eye that had me quaking at the knees as a youth. That one definitely comes in handy.
7. Dual Mom
November 5, 2009 @ 8:43 pm
I LOVE this post. My childre are very scared of my “evil eye”.